
This Thanksgiving I was in charge once again and decided to skip the turkey. I am not the biggest fan of this bird, nor all the “tricks” one has to do to add moisture or flavor. So I came up with what I think was a more satisfying menu for our day of thanks.
Lunch Course
We started just past noon with a soup, butternut squash soup with garlicky shrimp.

This recipe was based on several I’d made in the past; it included:
- 2-way cooked butternut squash (1/2 roasted, 1/2 cubed and sautéed with the vegetables)
- 1 leek
- 1 onion
- 1 apple
- sage
- 2 carrots
- homemade chicken stock
- 2 bay leaves
- brown butter (swirled in at the end)
- shrimp, sautéed in butter and garlic
- freshly ground nutmeg
- salt/pepper
The key here is the texture of soup; I like to blend it once it is cooked through (45 minutes after the broth is added), and then through a fine-keyed strainer (I didn’t use the plunger but simply a large wooden spoon). Instead of adding fried sage leaves, I added sage a few minutes before blending. The sage and brown-butter additions were learned from my flirtation with Thomas Keller’s version from Bouchon.
Dessert
One of my most memorable editions of Gourmet was their 2006 Thanksgiving edition from November. It had so many good recipes; one I had never made was the one for the macadamia nut and coconut tart. You can find it in the Epicurious app for iOS.

First step was to make a pie crust. I used a a 70/30 mixture of butter and shortening, as per their recipe. I used the food processor which makes it easy. It goes into a 10-inch tart shell pan with removable bottom.

The filling is not unlike pecan pie; roughly chopped, toasted macadamia nuts join coconut and brown sugar and eggs. It puffs up slightly, then falls when it comes out.

Beef, not Turkey
I have found in Richmond the best source for prime beef is Belmont Butchery, where we obtained a 2 rib, 6 pound prime ribs of beef roast.

Okay, it weighed more, but I figure it was 6 pounds with the bones. I salted and peppered it, in addition to studding the fat side with garlic before roasting.

I roasted it to about 125-127 degrees and let it rest for 15 minutes.

Three Sides
- Green Beans with Orange-Ginger Glaze
- Brussels Sprouts with Mushrooms and Crispy Shallots
- Yam-Yukon Gold Potato Gratin with Smoked Paprika and Cayenne

Among my favorites was the brussels sprout dish, too from the 2006 November Gourmet. Thyme and garlic scents the dish, and for mine, I used a pair of horn mushrooms and chantarelles.
The green beans use orange zest, ginger, and orange juice, and butter. Simple. Salt and pepper.
The gratin came from a recipe from Food 52. At first, I saw this recipe for a more classic pommel dauphinoise, but then since my dad likes sweet potatoes, I went for this one instead. It was good.

In all the meal was successful. Here are two more highlight photos:

and the dessert,

Happy Thanksgiving!